Cadillac is a piece of crap, rednecks must be here to polish this turd.

Boy Rob, I hope you don’t have to do ALL the showroom showdowns…
I’ll bet you get a lot of crap if you do…

Ok guys, some of you are missing the point of these little contests. The question is not, “Which is better?” The question is, “Which car would YOU rather own.” That’s it. I don’t pick the winners or attempt to influence the voting in any way.

Jalopnik Rules… if that IS your real name…
The editor of the article (Rob in this case) doesn’t choose the winner, there’s a vote. Go to the Showroom showdown section of the blog. You’ll find the bit where everyone voted right under the winner headline.
Also, give cardomain a chance, you might start to like it sooner or later. I’m a regular now over at jalopnik (I have the same username over there), but I like this place too.

FLK, why are you being such a jerk. I doubt you have driven any of these cars but you insist on pretending you know everything. Also, the latest RS4 went on sale in 2006, 2 years ago, its not 5 years old. And the platform is 3.5 years old, so STFU.

FLK, why are you being such a jerk. I doubt you have driven any of these cars but you insist on pretending you know everything. Also, the lastest RS4 went on sale in 2006, 2 years ago, its not 5 years old. And the platform is 3.5 years old, so STFU.

By what exact qualities did the Lexus win over the BMW? …Because if I recall, the BMW has beaten the Lexus in every major-magazine review I have read. The month’s R&T lists the cars as follows.

1st: Mercedes-Benz C63 AMG
2nd: BMW M3 Sedan
3rd: Audi RS4
4th: Lexus IS-F

When the “new” Lexus can’t beat over a five year old Audi in it’s last year of production, you have a problem. They mentioned its ugly (1), its not nearly as fun to drive (2), and the interior stack is too pedestrian (3). So “what” if it beat it in “Car domain”, because apparently every major magazine agrees that the Lexus can’t really overpower its tuetonic competition.

Whilst I respect the CTS-V for what it is, IMO its an ugly bugger of thing. The front-end styling belongs back in the ‘angular’ 80’s where most other manufacturers left their similar designs – horrible and not a patch on the Audi – any Audi for that matter.

But I like what the CTS-V is under the skin. I guess the perfect place would be behind the wheel…where you don’t have to look at it.

I am positive the editor of this article is biased….look at the all the comments you have hear cheering the RS4 even now when you gave your unqualified opinion choosing the other car – do you even do any research? Did you get beat by an Audi or something?

I am going back to Jalopnik…..where “REAL” car people write about cars. You write like a teenager who knows nothing about cars.

I think the CTS-V is now the king, with the CTC-V ready to take the honors in another year or two.